top of page



517 Dempster St, Evanston, IL 60201

Winter Hours:

Sun - Tues: Closed
Wed - Sat: 10am - 5pm


Creating a Unique and Pleasing Dessert Experience

Comfort Desserts is a creative homage to the loyalty and courage of a character featured in the Godfather film: Enzo, the Baker. From our signature Key Lime, Lemon Blueberry, and Passion Fruit pies to our 28 different flavors of bread pudding, our menu is designed to provide the most discriminating palate with something specially to its liking.

About Us

We only make four sheet cakes: carrot cake, hummingbird cake, coconut pineapple cake, and lemon cake. Each is designed to be eaten at room temperature or slightly warmed to make it a truly decadent dessert experience.

Our bakers’ creativity lies in showcasing the fruit, not sugar, in the cobblers: cherry, blueberry, blackberry, pear, and tropical fruit.  Each individual serving of bread pudding, cobbler, and sheet cake can be served with a small scoop of ice cream (or gelato, if available), should the customer desire – no extra charge. 

bottom of page